“Peter, do you love me unconditionally, without pretension? Do you love me more than you love these?” Jesus asks, pointing to the fish they were feasting on (Jn 21:15). Peter responds, “Lord, you know I’m fond of you as a friend.”

No More Than a Friend
Wait, hold it. What?
Where’s the “Call me out of the boat,” “You are the Christ,” “I’m the Rock (not Dwayne Johnson),” “You won’t go to the cross,” “Wash me head to toe,” “I would never deny. I would die for you,” over-promising, under-delivering Peter we’vecome to know? Somewhere between the courtyard denial and the seaside breakfast, Peter changed. The pain of not being first to speak, first to fight, first to lead, first at anything, gave way to the pain of not being able to follow through. Peter could have easily had his own morning radio show: “The Big Talker, Simon Peter, on radio station WWJD.” That Peter was gone.
He knew better than to exaggerate, over-promise, and over-brag in any given situation. Peter saw himself for the fraud he was or tended to be at times. He could talk a good game, but he couldn’t follow through. Peter was well aware of his glaring weakness. Jesus knew this, too. Jesus also knew Peter needed to know everything was okay. Peter needed to know Jesus still loved him. Peter needed to know there was still room for him at the table.
Jesus and Peter
Jesus knew all that, and pushes into Peter’s plight ever so gently. All Jesus needs to know is “Peter, are you willing to trust? Are you willing to try this again?”
“Good, Peter. I want you to keep a watchful eye on these guys.”
Then Jesus leans in a little closer and asks a second time, “Peter, can I ask you another question? Do you love me unconditionally?” (Jn 21:16).
Peter responds, “Lord, I am fond of you as best a friend could be fond of his friend.”
“Then I want to you step up and lead and guide my followers at large,” Jesus said.
One final time, Jesus pushes as close as he could with Peter. “Peter, do you even like me? Are you truly fond of me as a friend?” (Jn 21:17).
Peter’s Pain
This final time, Peter realizes what Jesus is getting at. He feels the sting and pain of what unfolded over the last several weeks. This meeting with Jesus was the third time he’d appeared to the men. The first time was the day of the resurrection, the second was the following Sunday with Thomas. Now this day. It was at least more than a week since Peter denied his friend and leader, Jesus. Enough time had passed for Peter to work through all that had happened. As with any broken friendship, Peter wasn’t sure if Jesus would take him back.
The Restoration of a Friendship
Here they stood, eye to eye, making sense of how far they’d come. Peter had denied. Jesus had died. Peter hoped for a second chance, and Jesus was offering Peter a second chance. But Peter didn’t know if he could trust himself. He knew his weakness to look the part but not live out his commitment.
He says as much to Jesus. “Lord, you know me. You knew I would deny you because you know everything. You know I’m fond of you. I can’t commit to loving you unconditionally, because when the conditions got tough, I bailed on you. I denied you. But you do know that I’m fond of you because I wouldn’t have come this far. I didn’t dive out of the boat just to have breakfast. I dove out of the boat to come to see you, to follow you.”
Jesus’ Restoration of Peter
I don’t think the three questions of “Do you love me?” were lost on Peter. He denied Jesus three times. Then he verbally committed his love and loyalty to Jesus three times. I think Jesus purposely did this in front of the others, as well. Peter publicly denied Jesus. Jesus publicly restored Peter.
That’s exactly what Jesus wanted to hear. “Peter, teach and guide my followers from this point on.” Jesus was affirming the one he had nicknamed the “Rock.” He told Peter who he was—a mentor, a leader, a teacher. All those roles Jesus had filled for the last three-years—Jesus passed the torch to Peter. Even with Peter’s massive failure of denial, Jesus was willing to work with him. His denial of Jesus was his setback. It wasn’t until Peter saw his setback that he stopped trying to compensate for what he thought he lacked.
We overcompensate all the time. We masquerade through life, trying to prove our worth by our silence, exuberance, arrogance, achievement, or self-righteous idealism. All these labels are self-imposed. Jesus came to remove labels and show us love. You don’t need a label to hide behind when you know you are loved. Peter needed no more labels. He knew he was loved. Peter no longer tried to prove who he was; he now knew who he was—Jesus’ friend and follower. Jesus doesn’t invite us to positions and traditions. Jesus invites us into a relationship with Him.
A Relationship with Jesus
A relationship is more than information about Jesus; it’s a relationship is a connection with Jesus. What information do you know? You know you’ve messed up. Your hope was crushed; you quit too soon. You know you held on to hurt instead of hope. Put aside what you know about you. Step into who you know—the one who knows you, Jesus. You can be well known to a world that will give you ten minutes of fame, or you can be known well by the one who calls your name.
Who You Are
When you know that who you are is not found in what you do, you can step into who Jesus says you are. Attempting to find our value in what we do always leaves us empty and asking for more. The respect, acceptance, approval, and attention Peter longed for was going to be the very thing he gave to those he mentored, led, and fed. I am living out who God created me to be and following Jesus the best when I give to others what I long to receive in my own life. The switch must flip from seeking people to fix and fulfill us; our calling is to fill others with what Jesus has filled us with—his love.
Which Do You Choose?
Some people are released. Some people are restored. Jesus released Judas, but he restored Peter. Restoration is offered to you and me. All Jesus wants to know is if we are willing to dive in and follow him. No matter what’s happened in our past, no matter the hurt of our pain, and no matter what the future holds, Jesus can restore our hope.
*This post is an excerpt from Matt’s book, Six Days to Sunday: Turn Setbacks Into Comebacks.
More Encouragement
For more encouragement, check out my post, Believe Again: Easter Hope for Everyday Faith.





